OSM Stream City vs Piaggio Ape e-City FX: A Comparative Analysis of Electric Auto Rickshaws
Electric vehicles are rapidly transforming the urban transportation landscape, offering an eco-friendly alternative to traditional combustion engines. Today, we delve into a comparative analysis of two popular electric auto-rickshaws in India: the OSM Stream City and the Piaggio Ape e-City FX. We will examine their features based on price, performance, battery, charging, and design.
Price
🏷️ OSM Stream City: Priced at ₹3.25 lakh, the Stream City targets the premium segment of electric auto rickshaws.
🏷️ Piaggio Ape e-City FX: At ₹1.95 lakh, the Ape e-City FX is more affordable, making it an attractive option for buyers on a tighter budget.
Performance
Max Power:
💪 OSM Stream City: Delivers a robust 10 kW of power.
💪 Piaggio Ape e-City FX: Offers 7.3 kw, which is lower compared to OSM but sufficient for city commuting.
Max Torque:
🏋 OSM Stream City: A high torque output at 430 Nm, significantly surpasses Piaggio, enhancing its ability to handle steeper gradients.
🏋 Piaggio Ape e-City FX: Provides 29 Nm of torque.
Range:
🚀 OSM Stream City: Provides a range of 100 km with an 8.5 kWh battery.
🚀 Piaggio Ape e-City FX: Edges out slightly with a 110 km range, although it has a smaller 5.44 kWh battery, showcasing efficient energy usage.
Charging and Battery
Charging Time:
🔌 OSM Stream City: Can be fully charged in 4 hours.
🔌 Piaggio Ape e-City FX: Takes slightly less time at 3 hours and 45 minutes.
Battery Capacity:
🔋 OSM Stream City: The larger 8.5 kWh battery suggests longer life and potentially fewer charging cycles.
🔋 Piaggio Ape e-City FX:Though smaller at 5.44 kWh, the battery is efficient, as indicated by its comparable range.
Design and Dimensions
Dimensions:
📐OSM Stream City: Measures 2870 mm in length, 1450 mm in width, and 1810 mm in height, providing a spacious cabin.
📐 Piaggio Ape e-City FX: More compact, with dimensions of 2700 mm x 1370 mm x 1725 mm, better suited for navigating narrow urban streets.
Ground Clearance and Wheelbase:
👓 OSM Stream City:A ground clearance of 175 mm and a wheelbase of 2120 mm.
👓 Piaggio Ape e-City FX: Higher ground clearance at 200 mm, beneficial for Indian road conditions, and a shorter wheelbase of 1920 mm which assists in tighter turning radii.
Colour Options
OSM Stream City: The Stream is available in four different colours, named
🌈 White
🌈 Black & Yellow
🌈 Blue
🌈 Green & Yellow
Piaggio Ape e-City FX: Piaggio Ape E-Xtra FX is available in only one colour option;
🌈 Blue
Conclusion
Choosing between the OSM Stream City and the Piaggio Ape e-City FX depends on your specific needs and budget. The OSM Stream City stands out in power and battery capacity, ideal for longer trips and heavier loads. In contrast, the Piaggio Ape e-City FX, with its efficient use of a smaller battery and slightly better range, along with a more affordable price tag, might appeal to those prioritizing economy and manoeuvrability in tight urban spaces.
Whether you prioritize performance, cost-efficiency, or specific features like faster charging times or higher gradeability, both models present compelling cases for transitioning to electric rickshaws in urban environments.